| (1) |
A. Using the grammar tool in generalized X' theory, build structures for the following sentences.
| (2) | a. | He claims that the owner will hire him. | |
| b. | I have investigated the claim that they are following him. | ||
| c. | She must be happy that they hired her. |
B. "Translate" the sentences in (2) into Engshil. Recall that Engshil is just like English, except that all of its lexical categories are head-final.
C. "Translate" the sentences in (2) into another imaginary variant of English in which lexical categories are head-initial, just as in ordinary English, but functional categories are head-final.
There is no need to provide trees for either (B) or (C).
| (3) | a. | He returned home after the war ended. | |
| b. | He returned home after the war. | ||
| c. | * | He returned home after. | |
| (4) | a. | Nobody broke in although they were gone for a week. | |
| b. | * | Nobody broke in although their week-long absence. | |
| (5) | a. | I came because I like you. | |
| b. | I came because of you. | ||
| c. | * | I came because you. | |
| d. | * | I came because. | |
| (6) | a. | He had never been abroad before the war started. | |
| b. | He had never been abroad before the war. | ||
| c. | He had never been abroad before. | ||
| (7) | a. | * | Nobody broke in despite they were gone for a week. |
| b. | Nobody broke in despite their week-long absence. | ||
| (8) | a. | * | The burglars broke in during they were gone. |
| b. | The burglars broke in during their absence | ||
| c. | * | The burglars broke in during. | |
| (9) | a. | They differ in that they don't share the same interests. | |
| b. | * | They differ in they don't share the same interests. | |
| c. | They differ in their interests. | ||
| (10) | a. | Winston tastes good like a cigarette should. | |
| b. | Actually, this cigarette tastes like crap. | ||
| (11) | a. | They haven't gotten a lot of sleep since their baby was born. | |
| b. | They haven't gotten a lot of sleep since their baby's birth. | ||
| c. | They haven't gotten a lot of sleep since. | ||
| (12) | a. | The burglars broke in while they were gone. | |
| b. | * | The burglars broke in while their absence. | |
| c. | * | The burglars broke in while. |
B. On the basis of the German data in (13)(15), provide all the necessary elementary trees for the italicized prepositions.
| (13) | a. | Bevor / nachdem du kommst, räumen
wir auf. before / after you come clean we up 'Before/after you come, we'll clean up.' | |
| b. | * | Bevor / nachdem deiner Ankunft räumen
wir auf. before / after your arrival clean we up Intended meaning: 'Before/after your arrival, we'll clean up.' | |
| c. | * | Bevor / nachdem räumen wir auf. before / after clean we up Intended meaning: 'Beforehand/afterwards, we'll clean up.' | |
| (14) | a. | * | Vor / nach du kommst, räumen wir auf. before / after you come clean we up Intended meaning: 'Before/after you come, we'll clean up' |
| b. | Vor / nach deiner Ankunft räumen wir auf. before / after your arrival clean we up 'Before/after your arrival, we'll clean up.' | ||
| c. | * | Vor / nach räumen wir auf. before / after clean we up Intended meaning: 'Beforehand/afterwards, we'll clean up.' | |
| (15) | a. | Während wir Studenten sind, verreisen wir. while/during we students are travel we 'While we are students, we travel.' | |
| b. | Während des Sommers verreisen wir. while/during the summer travel we 'During the summer, we travel.' | ||
| c. | * | Während verreisen wir. while/during travel we Intended meaning: 'During some unspecified time period, we travel.' |
C. Compare and contrast the syntactic behavior of after,
before, during, and while with that of their German
translation equivalents.
Exercise 4
A. How can the analysis of the possessive presented in Chapter 4 be modified to be consistent with
noun phrases like those in (16)?
| (16) | { my, your, his, her, our, their } book |
B. Does the modification you propose in (A) extend to the examples in (17)? Explain.
| (17) | the king of France's book, the queen of Sheba's palace |
| (18) | This is definitely one of them jobs, man, if you're one of them
worriers
(Overheard at Bessie's lunch truck, 34th and Walnut, Philadelphia, PA, 31 August 1999) |